Introduction
In the startup world, compensation isn’t always straightforward. Founders often face the tricky question: should we offer higher salaries, or use equity as a trade-off? The answer isn’t one-size-fits-all. The right mix depends on your growth stage, hiring goals, and company culture. Get it wrong, and you risk scaring off top talent—or diluting your cap table. Here’s how to strike the right balance between equity and salary.
Understanding the Trade-Off
Equity and salary are both powerful motivators—but they offer very different value:
- Salary: Immediate, reliable income that supports day-to-day life
- Equity: Long-term upside tied to the success of the company
The key is to align compensation with what the role demands—and what the candidate values.
When to Lean Toward Equity
Equity-heavy offers can be compelling when:
- You’re pre-revenue or bootstrapped: Cash is tight, but belief in your mission is strong
- You’re hiring early team members: They’re helping build the company from the ground up
- The role is strategic: You want long-term commitment and buy-in
- The candidate is entrepreneurial: They value upside more than guaranteed pay
When to Prioritize Salary
Offering competitive salaries makes more sense when:
- You’re scaling fast: You need talent ready to hit the ground running
- You’re in a competitive market: Candidates have multiple options
- You’re hiring for executional roles: Where predictability and consistency are key
- The candidate needs financial stability: Not everyone can afford to bet on equity
How to Structure a Balanced Offer
The best compensation packages combine both elements strategically:
- Base salary: Competitive within your industry and location
- Equity: Clearly defined in terms of percentage and vesting schedule
- Benefits: Health, PTO, flexibility—all part of total compensation
- Upside narrative: Help candidates understand your growth plan and what equity could mean
Communicating Equity Clearly
One of the biggest mistakes startups make is offering equity without explaining it. Be transparent about:
- Number of outstanding shares
- Company valuation (current and projected)
- Exit scenarios (acquisition, IPO, etc.)
- Vesting schedule and cliff
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Undervaluing execution roles: Not every role should be equity-heavy
- Overcomplicating offers: Confusing equity math can turn candidates off
- Ignoring market data: Benchmark against what competitors are offering
Conclusion
Equity vs. salary isn’t a battle—it’s a balancing act. The goal is to design compensation that reflects your company’s stage, your hiring priorities, and your values. When done right, it creates a team that’s motivated, aligned, and ready to grow with you.
Compensation isn’t just about cost—it’s about commitment.
👉 Need help designing a compelling compensation strategy?
Let’s create a plan that aligns incentives and attracts the right people.
📩 Connect with The Fifth Work on LinkedIn to get expert guidance for your next hire.
